Time for the next in our "Best of the Month" series.. At the time of it's original publication, Dr. Craig Horbinski had this to say about a study which had recently been published in Brain Pathology: "Only catch is whether the method is TOO sensitive. After all, if all
oligos are positive for IDH1, why do the "inferior" IDH tests
effectively stratify prognosis? I'll be keen to see if anyone else can replicate this work."
Here's the original post from October 22, 2012:
Although direct sequencing of mutations in isocitrate dehydrogenase 1 (IDH1) has been considered to be the gold
standard method to detect this mutation, the sensitivity of this
technique has been questioned especially because specimens from glial
tumors may contain large numbers of non-tumor cells. The group screened 141
cases of oligodendroglial tumors for IDH1 mutations using
peptide nucleic acid (PNA)-mediated clamping PCR and compared the
results with the results of direct sequencing, pyrosequencing, and
immunohistochemistry (IHC). Nested PCR was only performed in cases
having mutant IDH1 only discovered by clamping PCR. Using dilution experiments mixing IDH1
wild-type and mutant DNA samples, clamping PCR detected mutations in
samples with a 1% tumor DNA composition. Using PNA clamping PCR, the group
detected 138 of 141 (97.9%) cases with mutant IDH1 in the
series, which is significantly higher (P = 0.016; PNA clamping vs.
direct sequencing) than those of direct sequencing (74.5%),
pyrosequencing (75.2%), and IHC (75.9%). From these results, it appears that almost all
oligodendroglial tumors have IDH1 mutations, suggesting that IDH1 mutation is an early and common event especially in the development of oligodendroglial tumors.
I discuss issues pertaining to the practice of neuropathology -- including nervous system tumors, neuroanatomy, neurodegenerative disease, muscle and nerve disorders, ophthalmologic pathology, neuro trivia, neuropathology gossip, job listings and anything else that might be of interest to a blue-collar neuropathologist.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Neuropathology Blog is Signing Off
Neuropathology Blog has run its course. It's been a fantastic experience authoring this blog over many years. The blog has been a source...
-
Shannon Curran, MS with her dissection Shannon Curran, a graduate student in the Modern Human Anatomy Program at the University of Co...
-
Last summer I put up a post about a remarkable whole nervous system dissection that was carried out at the University of Colorado School of ...
1 comment:
Interesting. Just had an IDH-1+ oligo.
Post a Comment